Attracting Talent as a Small Broker: Why It’s Time to Stop Playing it Safe
The talent war is on, and smaller brokers need to stop waiting in line for leftovers. It’s time to rethink how we attract top talent—and no, free coffee won’t cut it.
Picture this: you're a small insurance broker, staring down the barrel of a hyper-competitive talent market. The big players are snatching up the best candidates with flashy perks, fat paychecks, and corporate clout. So, what’s left for you?
The answer: plenty—if you’re willing to play the game differently. It's time to rethink, reshape, and maybe even rebel against the traditional ways of attracting talent. Spoiler alert: the latest chromed Italian coffee machine won't save you.
The Insurance Times recently posed a crucial question: How can smaller brokers attract the right talent? Matt Scott's article highlights the uphill battle brokers face in a talent market dominated by bigger players with bigger budgets, drawing attention to the importance of building a unique culture and offering development opportunities as tools to level the playing field.
But here’s the thing: smaller brokers can and should do more than just compete—they should redefine what "winning" in recruitment even looks like. Inspired by Insurance Times’ insights, we’re diving deeper to explore how brokers can go beyond traditional recruitment strategies and use their agility to deliver on what candidates genuinely want today: purpose, flexibility, and an authentic culture. Because when you stop trying to play like the big guys, you might just end up outplaying them altogether.
The Problem with the Talent Status Quo
The insurance industry has long been a stalwart of tradition—and that’s precisely the problem. The old recruitment strategies simply don’t cut it anymore. Smaller brokers, in particular, are stuck playing catch-up, relying on conventional methods like job boards and local advertisements while the bigger fish dominate LinkedIn with employer branding campaigns that scream “Best Company to Work For” in neon lights.
But here’s the rub: candidates today are looking for more than just a job. They want a purpose. They want flexibility, culture, and a company that aligns with their values. Yet, many smaller brokers are still focused on the basics, offering the same old transactional package that’s about as enticing as General Liability.
Fathom Talent Attraction
Fathom provides rigorous research, evidence-backed strategies, and data-driven employer branding - from EVP to delivery.
The Disruptive Approach to Talent Attraction
So, how do you compete without a Fortune 500 budget? By refusing to play their game.
- Start with Purpose, Not Perks: Your mission is your biggest differentiator. While the large firms are fixated on flashy offices and bottomless lattes, smaller brokers can offer something far more valuable— agile and meaningful work. Insurance brokers play a critical role in helping people manage risk and protect their futures. Don’t downplay that. Lead with it.
- Flexibility is Non-Negotiable: The pandemic has flipped the working world upside down, and flexible working arrangements are no longer a “nice-to-have.” Smaller brokers have the unique advantage of being more agile—so why aren’t you using that to your benefit? Offer remote working options, flexible hours, or even a four-day workweek. The big players are often bogged down in bureaucracy, giving you the chance to outmaneuver them by being adaptable.
- Culture Eats Strategy for Breakfast: Team members want to feel like they belong, and a smaller company often offers a closer-knit, more personal environment than a corporate giant ever could. Focus on building a strong company culture where people can thrive, be heard, and make an impact. Encourage open dialogue, foster creativity, and make work a place where people actually want to be. You don’t need a sprawling campus—just an office where people feel valued.
But We Can’t Compete with the Salaries Big Firms Offer
I hear you. But here’s the thing—salary is only one part of the equation. While you may not be able to match a large broker's paycheck pound for pound, you can offer value in other areas. A clear path for career growth, faster professional development opportunities, and a work-life balance that doesn’t feel like a myth can be just as, if not more, appealing. According to Fathom’s own research, candidates prioritize culture and flexibility over salary in today’s market. So, stop trying to win the salary war and focus on where you can really shine.
How to Turn the Tables
Ready to step out of the shadows of the big players? Here’s how to start:
- Define Your Mission: What do you stand for? Why should someone work for you? If you don’t know the answers, neither will your candidates.
- Leverage Your Agility: Offer benefits the big firms can’t—whether it’s flexible working arrangements or direct access to leadership. Use your size as an advantage, not a handicap.
- Create a Magnetic Culture: Make your workplace a community. Invest in relationships, celebrate successes, and create an environment where people feel they can make a difference.
- Get Creative with Recruitment: Don’t just rely on job boards—think about where your ideal candidates are and meet them there. That might mean hosting an industry event, starting a blog, or even creating a social media presence that speaks to your company’s values.
Your Size Is Your Strength
Attracting top talent as a smaller broker isn’t about trying to outshine the big firms. It’s about playing a different game altogether. When you focus on what makes you unique—your mission, your agility, and your culture—you’re no longer competing on their terms. Instead, you’re standing out for all the right reasons.
So, the next time a candidate asks why they should join your team instead of the big guys, you’ll have an answer that goes beyond paychecks and perks. The question is—are you ready to give it?
Takeaways
Why is attracting talent a challenge for smaller brokers?
Smaller brokers often don’t have the same resources or brand recognition as larger firms, making it harder to attract top talent.
What can smaller brokers offer that larger firms can't?
Agility, flexibility, a closer-knit company culture, and the opportunity to make a direct impact.
How important is salary when competing for talent?
While important, salary is only one piece of the puzzle. Culture, mission, and flexibility are increasingly prioritized by candidates.
What’s the first step for smaller brokers looking to attract better talent?
Start by clearly defining your mission and values—these are what will resonate with the right candidates.
Can smaller brokers really compete with the perks of larger companies?
Yes! By offering meaningful work, flexible arrangements, and a strong company culture, smaller brokers can attract candidates looking for more than just a paycheck.
How can smaller brokers build a stronger employer brand?
Focus on authenticity, highlight what makes you different, and ensure your internal culture matches your external messaging.
What should small brokers avoid when trying to attract talent?
Avoid mimicking the big firms’ strategies. Instead, lean into your unique advantages like agility, purpose, and culture.
Did you enjoy reading this? Elevate your employer branding game. Subscribe for more fresh content and expert insights - it's free!
EBN Jobs - Global Employer branding Roles
Let’s be real: a great employer brand is about more than quirky seating and trendy perks. Your next career move should be built on substance—where your strategy defines the culture, not the furniture.
Ready to make a real impact? Join Employer Branding Jobs and discover roles where strategy matters more than style.
Comments ()