The Trust Deficit: How Fake Job Postings Are Undermining Employer-Candidate Relationships
As fake job postings flood the market—accounting for up to 40% of all listings—employer trust is plummeting. Here's why it happens, its impact on employer brands, and how businesses can fix the damage.
Imagine applying for your dream job only to discover it doesn’t actually exist. Sound far-fetched? Unfortunately, it’s not. Fake job postings are becoming alarmingly common, with some reports suggesting nearly 40% of job advertisements are bogus.
Ghost Jobs Haunt the Market
Job seekers are increasingly navigating a minefield of deceptive postings. Recent studies reveal startling statistics:
- 36% of job ads are fake.
- 4 in 10 companies admitted to posting at least one fake listing last year.
- One in five postings serves no real hiring purpose, designed instead for optics, data collection, or pipeline padding.
For candidates, these listings erode trust. For employers, they create an environment where suspicion becomes the default. And for the job market as a whole? The damage is immeasurable.
Why Do Employers Fake It?
The motivations behind fake job ads aren’t always nefarious. However, they are rarely justifiable:
- Pipeline Hoarding: Companies post roles to build a pool of candidates “just in case.”
- Market Perception: Open roles signal growth and innovation—key for investor relations and PR.
- Competitive Research: Fake ads bait candidates into sharing details about skills, salaries, or industry trends.
- Internal Misalignment: Sometimes, postings exist because hiring priorities haven’t been finalized, yet the HR machine churns on.
While these tactics might seem strategic in the short term, they often backfire spectacularly.
Fathom Talent Attraction
Fathom provides rigorous research, evidence-backed strategies, and data-driven employer branding - from EVP to delivery.
The Ripple Effects: Trust, Tarnished Reputations, and Talent Shortages
1. Trust Hits Rock Bottom
Job seekers now approach postings with scepticism. This erosion of trust creates barriers even for legitimate employers, as candidates second-guess authenticity.
2. Brand Reputation Takes a Beating
Being labelled as an employer who ghosts candidates or posts fake jobs isn’t just a bad look—it’s a PR disaster. Candidates talk, Glassdoor remembers, and once an employer is tainted, recovery is an uphill battle.
3. Reduced Candidate Quality
As trust diminishes, high-quality candidates may avoid applying altogether, fearing they’re wasting their time.
4. Industry-Wide Cynicism
The more common fake postings become, the more they weaken the hiring ecosystem, creating an atmosphere of distrust that affects all players.
Solutions: How Employers Can Rebuild Trust
While the temptation to game the system is real, businesses who care about their reputation need to embrace a more ethical approach to hiring:
1. Commit to Authenticity
- Post roles only when there is a genuine intent to hire.
- Regularly audit listings to ensure accuracy and relevance.
2. Communicate Transparently
- Clearly state hiring timelines and processes.
- Provide updates to candidates—even those who aren’t moving forward.
3. Focus on Employer Branding
Instead of signalling growth through fake ads, highlight achievements, employee success stories, and other genuine indicators of progress.
4. Build Talent Communities
Maintain long-term engagement with potential candidates through newsletters, events, and content rather than relying on speculative listings.
5. Own Your Mistakes
If your organization has used fake postings, acknowledge it and take steps to address concerns publicly. A sincere apology can go a long way in restoring trust.
A Market in Flux Needs Leaders, Not Fakers
The rise of fake job postings reflects a troubling trend in employer-candidate relationships. While short-term gains might tempt some organizations, the long-term cost—eroded trust, damaged reputations, and diminished candidate pools—is far greater. Employers must take the lead in rebuilding credibility, demonstrating that trust and transparency aren’t just buzzwords but cornerstones of their brand.
The question isn’t whether the job market will demand this shift—it’s whether your organization will be ahead of the curve when it does.
Takeaways
What is a fake job posting?
A listing that advertises a role with no intent to hire, often created for data collection, PR, or pipeline building.
Why are fake job postings harmful?
They erode trust, tarnish employer reputations, and reduce the overall quality of job applications.
How can job seekers spot fake ads?
Look for vague descriptions, repeated postings, or inconsistent communication.
What motivates companies to post fake jobs?
Reasons include pipeline building, competitive research, and projecting growth.
How common are fake job postings?
Reports suggest up to 40% of postings may be fake.
What’s the solution for employers?
Transparency, authenticity, and better communication are key.
What’s the long-term impact if this trend continues?
A job market rife with distrust, reduced candidate engagement, and weakened employer brands.
Did you enjoy reading this? Elevate your employer branding game. Subscribe for more fresh content and expert insights - it's free!
EBN Jobs - Global Employer branding Roles
Let’s be real: a great employer brand is about more than quirky seating and trendy perks. Your next career move should be built on substance—where your strategy defines the culture, not the furniture.
Ready to make a real impact? Join Employer Branding Jobs and discover roles where strategy matters more than style.
Comments ()