Key points
- Remote's people team, several of them with no engineering background, built its own applicant tracking system with Claude in nine months of part-time work.
- Candidates are fed up: 58% of US workers resent re-entering CV details, and 61% of Australian job seekers have abandoned an online application.
- Mobley v. Workday rolls on, with court filings showing about 1.1 billion applications rejected through systems using Workday software. Workday denies the allegations.
- Software price rises of 10 to 20% at renewal and this year's SaaS sell-off make building your own look tempting.
- Application volumes, EU AI Act duties, security and maintenance make a home-built ATS impractical for most employers.
- The ATS will survive, but buyers now have leverage, and much of the candidate experience is a configuration choice the employer controls.
In January 2026, Job van der Voort, founder of the payroll and employer-of-record company Remote, set his Chief People Officer a challenge at a team off-site: build an applicant tracking system with AI. Nine months later, Barbara Matthews's team switched it on. The builders were three recruiters, a sourcer, an executive assistant and a people transformation specialist, several with no software engineering background, working in Claude and Claude Code around their actual jobs. According to Matthews's interview with HR Brew, as reported by People Matters, the system now holds more than 24,000 applications and candidate records, and it took 7,000 new applications in a single week.
LinkedIn did what LinkedIn does. Within hours the ATS obituaries were being written, mostly by people pushing AI, and every recruiter who has ever lost an afternoon to a frozen requisition screen allowed themselves a small, private smile.
I get it. I've spent long enough around this industry to watch the ATS evolve from a glorified filing cabinet into a glorified filing cabinet with a chatbot bolted on, and I have yet to meet a candidate, recruiter or employer brand lead who loves theirs. So it's fair to ask... if a handful of HR people can build their own in a few months, why is anyone still paying enterprise prices for software that everybody hates?
Everybody hates it, and they have receipts
Start with the people on the receiving end. Monster's Application Black Box report, a survey of 1,002 US workers published this year, found 58% are frustrated at having to re-enter information that is already on the CV they just uploaded. Anyone who has applied for a job in the last decade knows the ritual. You upload your CV, watch the parser mangle it into a form that believes you have worked at "Microsoft Excel" since 2014, then type the whole thing in again by hand. Sixty-one per cent had hit an upload error or some other technical failure on a careers site, and 60% said their biggest frustration was not knowing whether a human ever looked at their application.
This is not an American peculiarity. WorkPro surveyed 5,600 Australian job seekers in late 2025 and found 61% had abandoned an online application at least once, nearly 40% because it was too long or had too many steps (HCL Review). Almost a third upload a CV and then manually re-enter the same details, and more than half say the worst systems make them start again from scratch. Abandonment was highest in healthcare, construction and logistics, which happen to be the sectors that can least afford to lose people right now.
Then there is the filtering. Harvard Business School and Accenture's Hidden Workers research found 88% of employers admit that qualified high-skill candidates are screened out because they don't match the exact job criteria, rising to 94% for middle-skill roles (The Register). That was 2021, before every vendor discovered the letters A and I. The machines have since been taught to rank and score as well as filter, trained on decades of human hiring decisions and all the prejudice that came with them.
Asked what should happen to applicant tracking systems, 19% of Monster's respondents said ban them outright. Only 6% think they work well as they are. Even wily old politicians can't survive numbers like these.
For those of us in employer branding, this is where it stings. Companies can spend serious money on careers sites, EVP, and videos of happy colleagues, then route every applicant through a form that looks like a 2009 tax return and end things with an unexplained automated rejection, a frustration cited by 52% of Monster's sample. The application is the precise moment someone has decided they want to work for you. Most ATS treat it as nothing more than a data entry problem.
Exhibit A: Workday
If you want the strongest case against the status quo, it is sitting in a federal courtroom in San Francisco, where hiring algorithms are having their day in court. Derek Mobley, a man of colour over 40, says he applied for more than a hundred roles at employers using Workday's platform and was rejected, often within minutes or overnight. His lawsuit, filed in 2023, alleges that Workday's screening tools discriminated on age, race and disability. Workday argued that employers make hiring decisions, not software vendors. Judge Rita Lin let the case proceed anyway, and the court has since authorised notice to a nationwide collective of applicants over 40, a group UC Today reckons could run into the tens of millions.
In June the judge refused to throw out claims under California law and allowed a disability claim to continue, which argues the software uses proxies such as gaps in employment. Court filings put the number of applications rejected through systems using Workday software during the relevant period at around 1.1 billion (HCAMag). That counts applications, and plenty of people will have been rejected many times over, but it's a big number either way. Even if every one of those rejections was perfectly fair, which looks unlikely to me, it represents a billion moments of employer brand delivered by a vendor most candidates have never heard of.
Naturally, Workday denies the allegations. It says its AI "does not make hiring decisions and is not designed to automatically reject candidates" and that its technology "looks only at job qualifications, not protected traits like race, age, or disability." The case hasn't been decided yet. Since June it has been grinding through the courts, with fresh fights over evidence and how far the class claims can stretch. What's interesting is how the defence leads: it claims the software doesn't decide who's rejected, the employer does, through the knockout questions, filters and scoring thresholds it chose to switch on. Hold that thought.
Why building your own suddenly looks sane
Five years ago, an HR team announcing it was building its own ATS would have got a few chuckles. Today it sounds almost reasonable, and the money markets seem to agree. Since late January, investors have been dumping software stocks in what one trader christened the "SaaS-pocalypse", on the theory that AI agents and coding tools will make expensive seat-based software look like a fax machine (HR Brew). In February, Jefferies downgraded Workday itself (MarketMinute). Around the same time, HR Brew reported, two CNBC reporters with no coding experience vibe-coded a working clone of a Monday.com dashboard in under an hour.
The cost of staying put isn't helping. Gartner, also cited by HR Brew, says enterprise software price rises of 10 to 20% at renewal are now common, outpacing CIO budgets. When your vendor is putting up the bill for a product your candidates hate and your recruiters quietly work around, building something yourself starts to look less like hubris and more like a smart move.
Plenty of companies are already at it. Retool's 2026 Build vs Buy report, based on 817 respondents, found 35% said their teams had built custom solutions to replace functionality previously provided by at least one SaaS product, and 78% expect to build more this year. Sixty per cent had built something outside IT's oversight in the past year, which will, no doubt, delight every security chief reading this.
Klarna got there first, at least rhetorically. In 2024 its CEO Sebastian Siemiatkowski told investors, "We just shut down Salesforce. Within a few weeks, we will shut down Workday" (Salesforce Ben). The tech press had a lovely time with this. Then, in March 2025, he clarified on X: "So no, we did not replace SaaS with an LLM." Klarna didn't deliver, but it feels like only a matter of time before somebody does.
Now read the small print
If we go back to the Remote example and look a little closer, we can see the project took nine months of part-time effort from six people. At the time of the interview, six hires had been made through it, and the team was "actively fixing the bugs and making improvements and add-ons on a daily basis". Some staff had initially aired their complaints in private channels before being encouraged to bring them to weekly "crit labs". Fair enough. That is what building software looks like. It is also worth remembering that Remote sells global HR infrastructure for a living, so it has every commercial reason to tell a "we are all builders" story.
Then there is volume. Greenhouse says the average job on its platform attracts around 254 applicants, and applications per recruiter are up 412%, as candidates use bots that apply to everything on their behalf. Its CEO, Daniel Chait, calls it an "AI doom loop" (Fortune), and that is before you count the fake candidates and phantom jobs already clogging the pipes. Remote's system has already swallowed 7,000 applications in a week, which is pretty good going. The harder test is year three: still secure, still compliant and still upright after a few hiring surges, a regulatory change or two and the departure of the recruiter who understood how it worked. All while the AI-polished CVs read identically and somebody still has to defend the shortlist.
Compliance is where most of these adventures quietly end. Under the EU AI Act, AI used in recruitment counts as high-risk. Most of the obligations that follow, including telling candidates when a high-risk system has helped make decisions about them, have been pushed back to 2 December 2027 (MintHCM). Some of the Act's transparency duties have applied since 2 August 2026. Layer on data protection law, retention rules, equal opportunities reporting, accessibility and a growing patchwork of local bias-audit regulation, with more to come if governments take up any of our suggested rules for fixing recruitment. When you buy an ATS, a decent chunk of that burden sits with the vendor and its lawyers. When you build one... you are the vendor.
And then security. In 2025, researchers got into McHire, the hiring platform Paradox ran for McDonald's, with the username and password "123456", leaving data on as many as 64 million applicants exposed (TechRadar). That was a well-funded specialist vendor. Now picture the same candidate data sitting in an app a recruiter vibe-coded over a long weekend. I mean, what could go wrong?
Meanwhile, the incumbents are getting bigger. In August 2025 SAP agreed to buy SmartRecruiters, and Workday announced it was buying Paradox, adding to the HiredScore acquisition it had already made (UNLEASH). Those are not the actions of an industry measuring itself for a coffin.
So, is the game up?
For the ATS itself, no. The boring things an ATS does are exactly the things a vibe-coded tool does badly: audit trails, integrations with payroll and HR systems, holding a mountain of personal data securely, and coping with industrial volumes without falling over. Remote can build its own because it is, in effect, a software company with an HR team attached. Most employers are the other way round.
The vendors shouldn't relax, though, because the threat has changed. For twenty years, ATS providers could rely on inertia. Switching was painful, building was unthinkable, and so the clunky forms and black-hole rejections survived renewal after renewal. That moat has just got a lot shallower. Every talent acquisition leader now has a credible line for the next contract negotiation: fix the candidate experience, or we'll build our own front end and keep you on as the database. Some will mean it. The smarter ones will build the parts candidates actually touch, the careers pages, application flows and communications, and leave the ATS doing the plumbing out of sight.
Employer brand teams should also stop treating the ATS as somebody else's problem. Remember Workday's defence: the software doesn't decide, the employer does. That cuts both ways. The double data entry, the 40-minute forms, the knockout questions that bin anyone with a career gap and the 2am rejections are mostly configuration choices made by someone inside the business. They are also employer brand decisions, whether or not anyone calls them that. If your careers site promises that every individual matters and your application process suggests otherwise, candidates will believe the experience.
The ATS will survive. The excuses for a bad one are running out.
Takeaways
Did Remote really build its own ATS with AI?
Yes. Remote's people team started in January 2026 and launched the system in October, using Claude and Claude Code alongside their day jobs. It holds more than 24,000 applications and candidate records, including records migrated from its previous system, and the team is still fixing and extending it daily.
Why do candidates dislike applicant tracking systems?
Mostly the friction and the silence. In Monster's 2026 survey, 58% were frustrated at re-entering CV details, 61% had hit a technical error and 60% didn't know whether a human saw their application. Unexplained automated rejections frustrated 52%.
What is the Workday lawsuit about?
Mobley v. Workday alleges that Workday's screening tools discriminated against applicants on age, race and disability. The court has authorised notice to a collective of applicants over 40 and, in June 2026, let California law and disability claims proceed. Workday denies the allegations and the case is undecided.
Should companies build their own ATS?
For most, no. A home-built system has to cope with huge application volumes, EU AI Act and data protection duties, security and ongoing maintenance. Building the candidate-facing layer on top of an existing ATS is a more realistic option for most employers.
What can employer brand teams do about a bad ATS?
Apply for your own jobs and audit the journey as a candidate would. Remove duplicate data entry, shorten forms, review knockout questions and rejection messages, and use the credible option of building in-house as leverage with vendors at renewal.